AEW Dark

Plot

The debut and the first season (October–December 2019)

Cody Rhodes announced the series on October 5, 2019 as a digital companion to Dynamite, debuting that following Tuesday.¹³ Episode one opens with Tony Schiavone at his desk, thanking the fans for making the Dynamite premiere the most-watched premiere in pro wrestling history, then hands the viewer straight into the ring.¹⁴ Everything on the card was taped October 2 at the Capital One Arena in Washington, D.C., before and after that week's Dynamite.¹⁵

The debut ran five matches of roughly six to ten minutes each, broken up by Schiavone's studio hype pieces and a quick Dynamite recap.¹⁶ Darby Allin beat Japanese veteran CIMA with the Coffin Drop in 6:59. Britt Baker submitted Penelope Ford with Lockjaw in 10:12. The match of the night went 9:16, with SCU's Frankie Kazarian pinning Marko Stunt after a tandem powerbomb and lung blower.¹⁷ There was also an eight-man tag with Private Party, Best Friends, Pentagon Jr., Rey Fenix, Jack Evans, and Angelico, and a Jurassic Express versus SCU rematch from All Out.¹³ Reviewers noted the first episode had more star power than the show would carry later, calling it a mostly pleasant hour of Dynamite leftovers.¹⁸

From there the weekly rhythm set in: matches taped in whichever city Dynamite had visited that week, uploaded Tuesdays at 7 p.m. ET.¹⁹ Episode 7, from Nashville, brought Kris Statlander's debut in tag action and a main event where the Young Bucks beat the Stronghearts' T-Hawk and El Lindaman with the Meltzer Driver, the match reviewers picked as the star of the episode. The same episode drew a mild complaint about an oversized Dynamite recap segment, with the suggestion that ten minutes be trimmed.²⁰

The October 29, 2019 episode closed with the kind of chaos Dark did best: a hardcore triple threat between Darby Allin, Jimmy Havoc, and Jack Evans, where three men kept breaking each other's finishers until only Allin was left standing. Evans hit a 450 splash onto a laid-out Havoc that looked like it broke Havoc in half, and Havoc still kicked out. Allin set up a table in the corner. Havoc stopped Allin on the top rope with an eye gouge, then delivered a top-rope piledriver through the table to Evans. And still the match would not end: as Havoc lay on the wreckage, Allin came off the top with a chair-assisted Coffin Drop onto Havoc and pinned Evans for the three. The win moved Allin's record to 3-3-1 while Havoc fell to 1-4 and Evans to 2-4.²¹

The 2019 run closed on December 31 with a Best of 2019 clip show, despite the series having existed for under three months. Its ending featured Darby Allin taking a hard head drop that one reviewer called one of the best-looking endings in a long time, with Jon Moxley also picking up a win to build his record. The special was rated A-, judged exactly what it needed to be: an hour and a half of AEW's core product, the wrestling itself.²²

Dark ran on for years beyond this first season, eventually running for years as the standing home for AEW's untelevised bouts and a proving ground for unsigned and developmental talent, before being canceled after its April 25, 2023 episode, in preparation for AEW's Collision.

Characters

• Tony Schiavone is the weekly host, the veteran WCW announcer who anchors the show from a studio desk between matches, hyping the bouts and recapping Dynamite.²³
• Darby Allin is the series' early breakout, the face-painted daredevil whose Coffin Drop ends matches and whose hardcore triple threat win is the first season's signature moment.
• The Young Bucks (Matt Jackson and Nick Jackson) are the executive vice presidents of AEW who still appear in the ring, closing episode 7 with the Meltzer Driver.
• Britt Baker, Penelope Ford, Frankie Kazarian, Marko Stunt, CIMA, Jimmy Havoc, Jack Evans, Kris Statlander, and Jon Moxley round out the early roster of featured names, with Dark serving as the place where newer signings like Statlander first appeared.

Interpretations and controversies

A December 2019 analysis argued that AEW had a storytelling gap: plot points established on YouTube shows like Being the Elite drew only 150,000 to 200,000 views, while Dynamite drew about 850,000 viewers, leaving casual fans missing pieces of the story. It proposed Dark, which already had a SportsCenter-esque vibe, become the hub that addressed those online plot points with interviews and clips.²⁴ Critics also debated the show's reliance on long Dynamite recap segments, with some calling for a shorter runtime.²⁰