General · EdgepediaOctober 3, 20265 min read

Baking It

Baking It is an American holiday baking competition television series that premiered on the streaming service Peacock on December 2, 2021, in which eight teams of two home bakers compete in themed challenges judged by a panel of four grandmothers for a cash prize and the title "Best in Dough"¹^•². It is a spin-off of the NBC craft competition Making It, created by Amy Poehler and Nicolle Yaron, and ran for two seasons³^•¹. A separate product of the same name is Baking It, a bakery business software platform; this article covers the television series.

Key fact	Detail
Premiere	December 2, 2021, on Peacock¹
Format	Eight teams of two home bakers face themed holiday challenges judged by four grandmother judges²
Hosts	Season 1: Maya Rudolph and Andy Samberg; season 2: Maya Rudolph and Amy Poehler⁴
Prize	$50,000 cash prize and the title "Best in Dough"⁵
Seasons	2; season 2 ran December 12, 2022 to January 9, 2023, five episodes plus an NBC holiday special¹^•⁶
Production	Universal Television Alternative Studio in association with Paper Kite Productions and 3 Arts Entertainment⁷
Recognition	Writers Guild of America Award, Best Quiz and Audience Participation, 2023 (winner)¹

Spoilers

Seasons

Season 1 premiered December 2, 2021, hosted by Maya Rudolph and Andy Samberg, who also executive produced alongside Amy Poehler⁴. Its six episodes included challenges such as three-tiered cakes representing the bakers' holiday past, present, and future, gingerbread houses, and a final feast to determine "Best in Dough"¹². Poehler appeared briefly at the start of the first episode, meeting Rudolph and Samberg outside the cottage shared by the two shows¹³.

Season 2 debuted on Peacock on December 12, 2022, with Amy Poehler replacing Andy Samberg as co-host alongside Rudolph; both hosted and executive produced⁴. The season consisted of five hour-long weekly episodes plus a celebrity holiday special that aired on NBC the same night, featuring Fred Armisen, Kristen Bell, Nicole Richie, and JB Smoove baking for charity⁶. Challenges included recreating an exploded cake, edible representations of the bakers' worst fears, modern takes on vintage recipes pulled from the Grannies' purses, and a sweet-versus-savory pie semifinal, ending with a January 9, 2023 finale in which teams created a centerpiece dish for their favorite holiday celebrations¹⁴. The season 2 cast included roommates, brothers, siblings, couples, and a mother-daughter pair among the sixteen contestants⁶.

Format

Each season brings eight teams of two amateur bakers, typically family members or friends, to a winter cabin for a holiday-themed competition²^•⁸. In season 1 the teams faced two Christmas-themed baking challenges per episode, and one team was sent home at the end of each episode until the remaining team was crowned "Best in Dough" in the finale⁹. The judging panel consists of four real-life grandmothers, billed as excellent amateur bakers in their own right, who offer what the show calls no-nonsense feedback¹⁰^•². The season 1 judges were Bubbe Norma, Gigi Sherri, Grandma Anne, and Nana Harriet¹⁰.

The series is described as a musical baking competition: the hosts perform choreographed theme songs, interludes, and full music videos between challenges¹¹. The NBCUniversal Formats catalog, which licenses the format internationally, describes episodes as built around two challenges, "Short & Sweet" and "Pie In The Sky", with the four grandmas judging and the winning team crowned "Best in Dough"⁸.

Production and reception

The show was commissioned by Peacock in 2021 as one of several unscripted spin-offs of NBCUniversal formats, alongside Top Chef Family Style³. It is produced by Universal Television Alternative Studio, a division of Universal Studio Group, in association with Poehler's Paper Kite Productions and 3 Arts Entertainment; executive producers across the seasons have included Poehler, Rudolph, Yaron, Pip Wells, Kate Arend, and Dave Becky⁷. Episodes run roughly 47 minutes and carry a TV-PG rating¹.

Reviewers highlighted the grandmother judges and the hosts' rapport as the show's strengths. The A.V. Club's review of season 2 called Poehler's chemistry with Rudolph, her close friend and frequent collaborator, the most delicious part of the season⁵. A Metacritic summary described it as a gentle, family-friendly baking show whose hosts occasionally break into song¹⁵. The series won the Writers Guild of America Award for Best Quiz and Audience Participation in 2023 and was nominated in the same category in 2024¹. Season 2 later made its linear television debut on NBC on Saturday, July 15, 2023¹⁶. TheTVDB lists the series status as ended, with its most recent episode airing January 9, 2023¹.

References

Topic: Encyclopedia › Arts and culture › Screen and stage › Film and television › Series and fictional screen worlds › Unscripted, reality, and web-native series › Reality and competition franchise editions › Reality and competition franchises — overview and format history › Premiered 1995 to 2021

Initially written Oct 3, 2026 · Reviewed: Oct 25, 2026 · Edited: Oct 15, 2026; Oct 21, 2026; Oct 25, 2026; Nov 1, 2026 · Last review: Oct 25, 2026

Notice something wrong?