General · EdgepediaOctober 3, 20267 min read

Firecreek

Firecreek is a 1968 American Western directed by Vincent McEveety, starring James Stewart as Johnny Cobb, a part-time sheriff and farmer who must confront a gang of outlaws led by Henry Fonda's character Larkin when they settle in his small frontier town.¹ It was produced by Warner Bros.-Seven Arts in association with CBS-Television's new film division, premiered at the Plaza Theatre in El Paso, Texas, on 24 January 1968, and opened in Los Angeles and New York City on 21 February 1968.²

Key fact	Detail
Release	Premiered El Paso, TX, 24 January 1968; Los Angeles and New York openings 21 February 1968²
Runtime and format	104 minutes; Technicolor; theatrical aspect ratio 2.35:1; mono sound¹
Director and writer	Vincent McEveety; screenplay by Calvin Clements²
Leads	James Stewart as Johnny Cobb; Henry Fonda as Larkin; Inger Stevens as Evelyn Pittman¹
Production	Warner Bros.-Seven Arts, Inc., co-production with CBS-Television's film division; budget around $2.5 million²
Filming	Began 5 December 1966 in Sedona, Arizona; continued in Thousand Oaks, California, and on the Warner Bros. back lot²
Music and photography	Original score by Alfred Newman; cinematography by William H. Clothier¹

Spoilers

Plot

Five freebooting adventurers from the Missouri range wars, Larkin, Earl, Drew, Norman, and Willard, ride into the frontier town of Firecreek and decide to remain there until Larkin recovers from a gunshot wound.¹ Fearing trouble, the local part-time sheriff, Johnny Cobb, leaves his nearby farm and his pregnant wife Henrietta to spend the night in town.¹ The town is quiet enough that Cobb's post is essentially honorary: he has no official badge, only a rough-hammered tin star made by his young son.³

While Larkin recuperates at a boardinghouse run by Mr. Pittman, he considers the arguments against lawlessness voiced by Pittman's granddaughter, Evelyn, a widowed nurse who tends his wound.¹ His men, however, terrorize the town and disrupt church services held by the itinerant Preacher Broyles. The townspeople plead with Cobb to drive the gang out, but he tries to reason with them instead.¹ TIME's 1968 review noted the sheriff's badge was emblazoned "SHERAF," hammered out of tin by his children, and that he carries no gun at the start.⁴

The turning point comes when Arthur, a simpleminded stableboy, tries to stop Drew from raping Meli, an unwed Indian mother, and accidentally kills the gunman. Cobb jails Arthur for his protection and returns to his farm for his wife's labor, but the gang forces the townsfolk to attend a wake for Drew and then hangs Arthur.¹ Cobb, knowing that Larkin's gang had lingered in Firecreek only because its defeated, uncompetitive residents never challenged them, at last picks up his gun. He kills Earl, Norman, and Willard but is wounded by Larkin; refusing to concede, he reaches for the gun Larkin shot from his hand, and is saved when Evelyn kills Larkin with a rifle shot.¹

Production

The 2 November 1966 issue of Daily Variety announced that Stewart and Fonda would team up for what was described as their first film together, under the working title Fury at Firecreek. In fact the two actors had appeared together as musicians in the 1948 comedy A Miracle Can Happen, also released as On Our Merry Way; both were also in How the West Was Won (1962) without sharing any scenes.²

Principal photography was originally scheduled to begin 28 November 1966 in Sedona, Arizona, but was moved back to 5 December 1966. The company then returned to California, filming on location in Thousand Oaks before moving to the Warner Bros. back lot; an item in the 8 February 1967 Daily Variety indicated filming had recently been completed.² Location scenes were filmed in Arizona and California.¹ A production note of the period records that Jacqueline Scott, who played Cobb's pregnant wife, was herself expecting a child in March 1967.²

Director Vincent McEveety and producers Philip Leacock and John Mantley came primarily from television, having worked on the Western series Gunsmoke; McEveety also directed a number of Star Trek episodes.⁵ Fonda praised McEveety's work with actors, crediting him with not letting Stewart "get away with" his usual mannerisms, "things Jimmy Stewart has used to make a caricature of himself almost."⁵

Cast

The supporting cast drew on established character actors: Inger Stevens as Evelyn Pittman, Gary Lockwood as Earl, Dean Jagger as Whittier, Ed Begley as Preacher Broyles, Jay C. Flippen as Mr. Pittman, Jack Elam as Norman, James Best as Drew, BarBara Luna as Meli, Brooke Bundy as Leah, and Jacqueline Scott as Henrietta Cobb.¹

Reception and critical comparison

Contemporary reviews were measured. The New York Times of 22 February 1968 gave the film faint praise, calling it "a good, sturdy and occasionally powerful little Western" and "an unpretentious little color movie which looks as though it cost a dime" that "is almost exactly right every step of the way." Daily Variety felt it would need "a hard-sell campaign" because it lacked "the dash and action of a slam-bang western," and the Los Angeles Times deemed it "a workmanlike but wearily familiar western, quilted from so many other westerns including High Noon."² Roger Ebert, writing in the Chicago Sun-Times, found that the parts did not quite come together: "The tension we need to draw us into the story isn't there; things move at too leisurely a pace." He nonetheless noted tender scenes between Stewart and his pregnant wife and between Fonda and Stevens, and read the ending as a confrontation of "reluctant heroism (Stewart) and reluctant evil (Fonda), both wear[ing] gray hats."⁶ TIME quipped that Fonda, "strained, sensitive and introverted as ever beneath a bad-guy black hat," seemed "in need of a shrink more than a sheriff," and concluded the film would have been better "if that nice Mr. Fonda hadn't got in with the wrong crowd."⁴

High Noon and the law-and-order Western. TCM's retrospective essay describes the plot as a throwback to High Noon (1952), with Stewart in the Gary Cooper role of a pacifist lawman who must single-handedly protect a town of cowards, and, as in that film's climax, saved from certain death by a gun-wielding woman, though not his wife.⁵ A scholarly chapter on cold-war Westerns groups Firecreek with Anthony Mann's Tin Star (1957) and Edward Dmytryk's Warlock (1959) as "law-and-order Westerns" that reworked High Noon's tale of a lone lawman defending a community, treating the nature of the American community and the responsibilities of citizenship and power.⁷

Brutality and the Spaghetti Western. The same TCM essay argues that the film's violence, an attempted rape scene, Stewart's killing of an outlaw with a pitchfork through the chest, ugly dirty villains, and Alfred Newman's moody score, reflected the influence of the European-produced "Spaghetti Westerns" that had made Clint Eastwood a star.⁵ A University of North Texas thesis reads the town itself as a symbol: Firecreek is called a "cemetery of a town" by the gang of hired killers, a sterile garden where "no one has to compete" and people "bury" themselves instead of moving farther West.⁸

Fonda as villain and later history

Playing the heavy was unfamiliar territory for Fonda, whose screen image had been built on Abraham Lincoln (Young Mr. Lincoln, 1939), Wyatt Earp (My Darling Clementine, 1946), and Tom Joad (The Grapes of Wrath, 1940). In Firecreek he delivered lines such as "I always say if a man's worth shootin', he's worth killin'." In his autobiography he later wrote, "I played a bad guy who tried to kill Jim Stewart. Now, any man who tries to kill Jim Stewart has to be marked as a man who's plain rotten." A year later he played an even colder killer in Sergio Leone's Once Upon a Time in the West (1969).⁵

Stewart and Fonda, good friends in real life, reunited shortly afterward for the Western comedy The Cheyenne Social Club (1970).⁵^•³ After NBC televised Firecreek in 1972 and early 1973, producer Quinn Martin planned a "nonviolent oater" series based on the film, but nothing came of the project.² The film was released on home video in the United States on 18 May 1994¹ and is available on digital platforms, where it holds an IMDb rating of 6.8/10 from about 4,500 votes.⁹

References

Topic: Encyclopedia › Arts and culture › Screen and stage › Film and television › Films and standalone screen works › Individual films by title and year › Action and adventure films (individual works) › Westerns before 1980 › Released 1961 to 1979

Initially written Oct 3, 2026 · Reviewed: Oct 25, 2026 · Edited: Oct 15, 2026; Oct 25, 2026; Nov 1, 2026 · Last review: Oct 25, 2026

Notice something wrong?