General · EdgepediaOctober 3, 20265 min read

Goodbye, Columbus

Goodbye, Columbus is a 1969 American comedy-drama film directed by Larry Peerce, adapted by Arnold Schulman from Philip Roth's 1959 novella of the same name, and starring Richard Benjamin as Neil Klugman and Ali MacGraw as Brenda Patimkin. It was produced by Stanley R. Jaffe for Willow Tree Productions and financed and released by Paramount Pictures, opening on 3 April 1969.¹

Key fact	Detail
Release	3 April 1969, New York and Los Angeles; Technicolor, English, rated PG¹^•²
Runtime	105 minutes per the AFI Catalog; 102 minutes per Paramount and The Numbers¹^•²
Source	Philip Roth's novella from his 1959 first book, which won the 1960 National Book Award for Fiction¹^•³
Principal cast	Richard Benjamin (Neil Klugman), Ali MacGraw (Brenda Patimkin), Jack Klugman (Ben Patimkin), Nan Martin (Mrs. Patimkin)⁴
Box office	$10.5 million in U.S. and Canadian rentals, the ninth best-selling film of 1969 per Variety; The Numbers lists $22,939,805 domestic gross¹^•⁵
Awards	Nominated for the Academy Award for Best Screenplay Based on Another Medium⁶
Debuts	Richard Benjamin's first feature film and Ali MacGraw's first starring role¹

Spoilers

Plot

Neil Klugman, a college dropout recently discharged from the Army, lives in his Aunt Gladys' Bronx apartment and works in a local library. At a country club he meets Brenda Patimkin, a vacationing Radcliffe student from a nouveau riche Jewish family in Westchester County, and begins dating her despite his disdain for her affluent way of life. Mrs. Patimkin doubts Neil's ambition, but Brenda invites him to stay at her house for his two-week vacation, and the two make love nightly in her room. When Neil learns Brenda has stopped taking birth control pills because they make her sick, he insists she be fitted for a diaphragm. After Ron Patimkin's lavish wedding, Brenda returns to Radcliffe and invites Neil to Boston, where she reveals that her mother found the diaphragm.¹

The class contrast between Neil's lower-middle-class Newark background and the Patimkins' suburban wealth is the story's central tension, alongside questions of Jewish identity, sexuality, and self-knowledge.⁷

Production

The 29 January 1968 Daily Variety announced that Paramount would finance and release the adaptation. First-time producer Stanley R. Jaffe said that when he found the book, despite fifteen editions over ten years, had never been optioned for film, he "moved quickly," hired Arnold Schulman to write the screenplay, and made a deal with Paramount.¹

Locations. Principal photography was scheduled for 17 June 1968 but pushed back to 8 July, beginning at a $175,000 Colonial mansion in Purchase, New York, a hamlet in the Westchester County town of Harrison that stood in for the Patimkin family's milieu; the rest was shot in New York City. Jaffe and Peerce had wanted to film in Philip Roth's hometown of Newark, where the novella is set, but Newark's airport created a constant noise problem. Mayor John V. Lindsay's 1967 agreement with more than a dozen movie industry unions had made New York street filming more reliable and affordable.¹

The wedding scene. In the fifth week of the eight-week shoot, the Patimkin wedding and reception were filmed in the grand ballroom of the Hotel Delmonico at 502 Park Avenue and Fifty-Ninth Street. Opera star Jan Peerce, the director's father, played a Patimkin relative, and his voice coach and accompanist, cantor David Benedict, played the officiating rabbi; sixty costumed extras joined the principals in a scene in which ravenous guests mobbed the wedding buffet table. The "Patimkin Kitchen and Bathroom Sinks" factory scenes were shot at the Webster Plumbing Supply Warehouse on Webster Avenue in the Bronx.¹

Screenwriter Arnold Schulman wanted to keep the diaphragm scene, so he had Brenda explain to Neil that she was allergic to the pill.¹ Charles Fox scored the film, and the title song was performed by The Association.²^•¹

Reception

The film opened on 3 April 1969 at Elson's Forum and Loew's Tower East in New York and at one theater in Los Angeles, after a planned 19 March date was pushed back. It benefited from the success and controversy of Roth's then-current novel Portnoy's Complaint.¹ Reviews were generally positive but with reservations. Charles Champlin of the Los Angeles Times called it "ruthlessly honest, and unsparing in its look at those who have finished in (and out) of the money," while adding that some of the authenticity "felt uncomfortably like anti-Semitism."¹ Time praised the film for preserving Roth's "sexual candor" and "sour salt of Jewish skepticism," though it faulted the movie for imitating The Graduate.⁸ The Film Society of Lincoln Center notes that some critics felt the wedding scene crossed the line from affectionate ethnic humor into self-hating caricature.⁹

On Rotten Tomatoes the film holds a 93% Tomatometer from 14 reviews and a 51% Popcornmeter audience score.¹⁰ It received an Academy Award nomination for Best Screenplay Based on Another Medium.⁶

Place in Roth's screen career

Goodbye, Columbus was the first of Roth's works adapted for the screen, followed by Portnoy's Complaint in 1972. Gerard O'Donoghue, author of the "Roth in Adaptation" chapter in Philip Roth in Context (Cambridge University Press, 2021), counts eight Roth works adapted into films with mixed success, with Roth's work largely absent from Hollywood between the 1984 television version of The Ghost Writer and later adaptations of The Human Stain, The Dying Animal, The Humbling, and American Pastoral.¹¹ The Film Society of Lincoln Center calls it generally considered the more successful of the "Jew Wave's" two high-profile Roth adaptations.⁹

References

Topic: Encyclopedia › Arts and culture › Screen and stage › Film and television › Films and standalone screen works › Individual films by title and year › Comedy and romantic films (individual works) › Comedies of the 1960s

Initially written Oct 3, 2026 · Reviewed: Oct 25, 2026 · Edited: Oct 15, 2026; Oct 25, 2026; Nov 1, 2026 · Last review: Oct 25, 2026

Notice something wrong?