Potter Puppet Pals

Plot

Potter Puppet Pals has no single storyline. It is a parade of self-contained sketches, each a few minutes long, in which the Hogwarts cast acts out exaggerated, usually stupid versions of themselves. The closest thing to a throughline is the cast itself: six core puppets, plus one vegetable.

Season One (2003)

On September 27, 2003, "Bothering Snape" opens with Harry and Ron hovering around Snape saying "bother, bother, bother" until the dour potions master loses his mind. It is barely a plot and entirely a premise, and it works. The second episode, "Trouble at Hogwarts" (December 15, 2003), adds Hermione and Voldemort to round the cast to six and gives the puppets a real crisis: Voldemort attacks the school, and the heroes respond with the tactical brilliance of felt. Neil animated both cartoons piece by piece, without tweening, a process he described as "tedious," which is part of why the animated era ended after only two episodes.

Season Two (2006–2009)

After a three-year gap, the series relaunched on YouTube on September 26, 2006 with "Potions Class," now filmed with real hand puppets sewn with help from the Cicierega siblings' mother. The puppets' googly eyes and floppy arms became the series' signature look, and the humor got looser and weirder. Sketches bounce from potions lessons gone wrong to Dumbledore's senility to Snape's depressing home life.

In "The Mysterious Ticking Noise," released March 23, 2007, Snape hears a ticking sound in his dungeon and, rather than investigate it like a sensible wizard, begins chanting "Snape, Snape, Severus Snape" in rhythm with it. Dumbledore wanders in and adds "Dumbledore!" to the beat. Ron contributes a cheerful "Ron, Ron, Ron Weasley!" Hermione harmonizes, and Harry arrives to sing his own name with maximum self-satisfaction, the whole cast layering their names into a bubbling a cappella loop while the camera cuts between them like a music video. The joke builds and builds, and then Ron, poking around, discovers the source of the ticking: a pipe bomb. The explosion wipes the stage, and from the smoke rises Voldemort, who sings his own name to the tune of "Lollipop" by The Mudlarks. That is the entire episode: one joke, executed with escalating precision, ending in the Dark Lord crooning. It became the series' defining artifact, the 22nd most-viewed video on YouTube as of January 1, 2013, and a 4K remake was posted on March 23, 2017 for its tenth anniversary.

Other sketches push the puppet logic to its limits. In "Draco Puppet," the only appearance of Draco Malfoy, Harry sings a taunting song at a tiny Malfoy puppet and then puts him on a stove and burns him. Tom Riddle, in his appearance, is polite and oddly non-threatening, performing a number called "AVADA KEDAVRA!!!" in which he cheerfully declares that "killing people has never been this much fun." And then there is Neville.

In Neville's birthday episode, the series commits to its cruelest and most absurd gag: Neville, who is a butternut squash with a drawn-on face rather than a puppet, is killed and cannibalized by Harry, Ron, Hermione, Snape, and Dumbledore. The main cast eats him. He later returns as a ghost, because in this universe even a squash gets an afterlife. Beloved characters, unspeakable act, total deadpan.

Season Three (through 2015)

The final episodes arrived sporadically through the 2010s, with the last one airing October 29, 2015. The sketches grew longer and rougher in tone, leaning harder on swearing and toilet humor. Live shows became as big a part of the franchise as the videos: for five years the puppets performed at the annual Yule Ball in Cambridge, Massachusetts, alongside wizard rock band Harry and the Potters, a circuit the puppets still occasionally visit.

Characters

• Harry Potter (puppeteered by Neil Cicierega): Arrogant, vain, and convinced of his own fame, far less heroic than his book counterpart and far more likely to sing about himself.
• Ron Weasley: Dim but loyal, and the character most likely to discover the pipe bomb.
• Hermione Granger: Her bookishness is inflated to the point of caricature, making her the straight man in a world with no straight men.
• Severus Snape: Miserable, put-upon, and the series' breakout star; his name is the hook of its most famous song.
• Albus Dumbledore: Senile, cheerful, and devoted to "naked time," a recurring bit in which the headmaster disrobes for no reason at all.
• Voldemort: The Dark Lord reduced to a singing punchline, less menacing than in the books and much more musical.
• Neville Longbottom: A butternut squash with a face drawn on. Do not get attached.
• Draco Malfoy: Appears once, briefly, and combustibly.

Interpretations and controversies

Fans and critics have argued since the mid-2000s about whether the move from clean Flash animation to grainier live-action puppet footage was a step down. A contemporary review called the first two animated episodes "full flair at a perfect pace and length" while faulting later episodes for running long and leaning on swearing and toilet humor. The counterargument is the view count. Fans also produced their own Potter Puppet Pals videos beyond Neil's originals, making it one of the early web series whose fandom effectively continued it without him.

Sequels, spin-offs, and adaptations

The series adapts J. K. Rowling's Harry Potter novels and films, unofficially and with maximum disrespect. Its afterlife includes the 4K remake of "The Mysterious Ticking Noise" (2017), live performances at the Yule Ball and Harry and the Potters events, and a puppet Twitter account. Creator Neil Cicierega went on to further internet fame with his music project Lemon Demon and the Animutation cartoons that preceded this series.