General · EdgepediaOctober 3, 20267 min read

The Desperate Hours

The Desperate Hours is a 1955 American crime drama directed by William Wyler, in which three escaped convicts take a middle-class suburban family hostage in its own home while waiting for money that will fund their getaway. It was produced by Paramount Pictures from Joseph Hayes's best-selling 1954 novel and his 1955 Broadway play of the same name, and it is regarded as the prototypical "family-trapped-by-criminals" drama.¹^•²

Key fact	Detail
Release	New York opening 5 October 1955; Los Angeles opening 13 October 1955; 112 minutes, black and white, VistaVision¹
Source	Joseph Hayes's 1954 novel (first published in Collier's) and his play, which opened on Broadway on 19 February 1955 with Karl Malden as Dan and Paul Newman as Glenn¹
Principal cast	Humphrey Bogart (Glenn Griffin), Fredric March (Dan Hilliard), Martha Scott, Arthur Kennedy, Dewey Martin, Robert Middleton, Mary Murphy, Richard Eyer²
Real-life basis	The 1952 hostage-taking of Pennsylvania residents James J. and Elizabeth Hill by escaped federal penitentiary convicts; their $300,000 privacy lawsuit against Hayes, Paramount, and Random House was dismissed¹
Honors	The play won the Tony Award for Best Play in 1956; Wyler won the National Board of Review Award for Best Director for 1955³^•⁴
Remake	Desperate Hours (1990), directed by Michael Cimino, with Mickey Rourke and Anthony Hopkins; a critical and commercial failure⁵

Spoilers

Story

The story begins in Terre Haute, Indiana, where three men escape from the federal prison and flee to Indianapolis, taking the Hilliard family hostage while they wait for money to be delivered. Dan and Eleanor Hilliard, their daughter Cindy, and young son Ralphie find their northside home and their lives under the command of the escapees. As days pass and the money does not arrive, tempers fray; Dan tips off the police, Cindy's boyfriend sneaks into the house, and Ralphie slips a note to a teacher. Police piece the clues together, set a stakeout, and rescue the family; all three escapees are killed by the end of the film, and none is apprehended alive.³^•¹⁵

In the film, the convicts are Glenn Griffin (Humphrey Bogart), his kid brother Hal (Dewey Martin), and fellow prisoner Kobish (Robert Middleton). They deliberately choose the suburban home of department store executive Dan Hilliard (Fredric March) and force the family to carry on normal routines so neighbors and police grow suspicious of nothing. The authorities are alerted when March, at Bogart's behest, draws money from the bank for the convicts' getaway, and March begins subtly turning the tables.²

Wyler and Hayes aimed at a distinctive kind of tension. In Wyler's own account, the audience first wants the police to reach the criminals, but it slowly dawns on viewers that things might be much worse for the Hilliards if the police do come; forcing the audience to face that question puts them inside Dan Hilliard's anxiety.⁶ A contemporary Harvard Crimson review singled out the "Kafka-like mixture of horror and routine" and March's performance as a man left alone with his own courage in a situation where society cannot help him.⁷

Origins and the Hill lawsuit

Hayes, an Indianapolis native who worked as a playwright, novelist, and screenwriter, first wrote the story as a novel and then adapted it for stage and screen. He had been interested in the "hostage theme" as far back as 1946, when he wrote an article for Woman's Home Companion about a family held hostage by criminals.³^•⁸

According to a July 1956 Variety article summarized in the AFI Catalog, the story was inspired by the real-life hostage-taking of James J. and Elizabeth Hill of Pennsylvania, who in 1952 were held captive in their home by escaped federal penitentiary convicts; a February 1955 Life magazine article identified their ordeal as the basis of Hayes's story. The Hills, who had not been harmed by the convicts, filed a $300,000 right-to-privacy lawsuit against Hayes, Paramount, and publisher Random House, arguing that the comparisons embarrassed and distressed them. Judge Saul S. Streit dismissed the complaint.¹ Hayes himself attended the film's midwestern premiere in Indianapolis on October 26, 1955, and told the audience that his story, while set in Indianapolis, was not based on any specific local incident.³

Production and casting

The play reached Broadway only after the film had been shot. Hayes's stage version opened on February 19, 1955, shortly after filming ended, and both the novel and the play are credited onscreen.¹ Production ran from mid-October 1954 to January 25, 1955.¹

Casting reversals. The convict leader was written for a much younger man, which is why the 30-year-old Paul Newman could play him on Broadway; Hayes, adapting his own novel, rewrote the character for Bogart, reasoning that a closer age match between convict and household head would sharpen their antagonism.²^•⁶ The father's role was originally intended for Spencer Tracy, but the plan fell through when Tracy and Bogart could not agree on who would receive top billing, and Fredric March was cast instead.² Bogart had tried to buy the rights to the novel for himself but agreed to the picture when Paramount outbid him.⁶

Wyler's famously repetitive method was on display: he had March and Martha Scott kiss each other goodbye at the front door roughly 50 times, wearing March out so he would look suitably harried for a scene in which his character was late for work.⁶ The film was shot in Paramount's VistaVision widescreen process.¹ Gail Kubik, then a celebrated classical composer, wrote the score, which was heavily cut for theatrical release.⁹

For Bogart, whose health was failing, the film was his penultimate screen appearance; he died of cancer in 1957, a little more than a year after its release.⁹

Reception and legacy

The film earned an 88% Tomatometer on Rotten Tomatoes, and critics have consistently ranked it above the remake. Reviewers have praised Wyler's taut direction, Lee Garmes's cinematography, and March's performance as the beleaguered father, which one critic called one of the year's finest.¹⁰ The film proved more popular with critics than with audiences, possibly because the leads were considered past their prime.¹⁰ A scholarly chapter on Wyler's gangster films argues that the movie shows the genre's range, since a story confined to a few days cannot depict a criminal's rise and instead builds drama around a gangster in distress.¹¹

The 1990 remake. Michael Cimino's Desperate Hours (1990), with Mickey Rourke as escaped killer Michael Bosworth and Anthony Hopkins as the father, renamed every character from the original (the Hilliards became the Cornells) and modernized the plot; it was filmed in Utah, including Salt Lake City locations and Zion National Park.¹² The remake holds a 29% Tomatometer, and Roger Ebert, the film critic of the Chicago Sun-Times, judged that Cimino had turned the heat up too high on a 1950s crime classic, producing an overwrought melodrama.⁵^•¹³ The Deseret News found it more jumpy and violent than the original, with none of the civility that distinguished the first film.¹⁴ Paramount's own page dates the remake to 1991, while the AFI Catalog, Rotten Tomatoes, and Ebert's review all date it to 1990.²^•¹²

The premise itself was not new even in 1955: the 1951 John Garfield film He Ran All the Way uses the same situation of a criminal hiding from the law by terrorizing an innocent family, and Bogart had played a fugitive holding citizens hostage in The Petrified Forest (1936).¹³^•⁶

References

Topic: Encyclopedia › Arts and culture › Screen and stage › Film and television › Films and standalone screen works › Individual films by title and year › Crime, thriller, and mystery films (individual works) › 1950s films

Initially written Oct 3, 2026 · Reviewed: Oct 25, 2026 · Edited: Oct 15, 2026; Oct 25, 2026; Nov 1, 2026 · Last review: Oct 25, 2026

Notice something wrong?