The Matchmaker

Plot

Yonkers, New York, 1884. Horace Vandergelder (Paul Ford) runs a hay-and-feed store with a miser's grip on his cash and a half-formed intention of remarrying. He has engaged Dolly Levi (Shirley Booth), a widowed matchmaker with a passion for rearranging other people's lives, to find him a suitable wife, ideally one with money. Dolly has produced a candidate: Irene Molloy (Shirley MacLaine), a young widowed milliner in Manhattan. What Horace does not know is that Dolly intends the match for herself, and has from the first scene, where she is already confiding her plans straight into the camera.

Horace's chief clerk, Cornelius Hackl (Anthony Perkins), a grown man who has never once had an adventure, decides that today is the day. He and junior clerk Barnaby Tucker (Robert Morse) shut up the store while the boss is away and take the train to New York with ten dollars between them, armed with a to-do list: have a good meal, be in danger, almost get arrested, and kiss a girl. Dolly, who has engineered the whole afternoon, steers them straight to Irene Molloy's hat shop.

The hat shop sequence is the film's centerpiece of farce. Cornelius and Barnaby arrive at Irene's shop just as word comes that Horace himself is on his way to call on her, and the two clerks, caught in a closed store with the woman their boss is courting, have nowhere to go. They hide behind a screen while Irene and her assistant Minnie Fay improvise wildly to keep Vandergelder from discovering them, and the scene builds through whispering, slamming doors, a stuffed handbag, and a hat that has been sold to Cornelius and cannot be paid for. When Horace finally inspects the shop, he finds nothing but is left with the nagging sense that something is wrong, and the boys escape into the street with an unpaid hat, two new acquaintances, and the beginnings of the kisses on their list.

The afternoon snowballs toward dinner. Cornelius and Barnaby, now escorting Irene and Minnie Fay, resolve to eat at the Harmonia Gardens, the city's grandest restaurant, on money they do not have; Dolly, meanwhile, has invented a fictional rich widow named Ernestina Simple to lure Horace to the very same restaurant that evening. The threads all pull tight at once: the clerks are dining on Horace's credit, Dolly is dining in disguise, and Vandergelder walks into the Harmonia Gardens looking for a rich widow and finds his own clerks at his own expense. The resulting chaos, the pocketbook, the spilled secrets, the young couples aligned against the old man, ends with Vandergelder publicly humiliated and outmaneuvered.

Then comes the film's real ending. Dolly, unmasked as the author of all of it, tells Horace plainly that she has manipulated him from the start and that she intends to marry him herself. Booth plays the confession without a shred of apology: Dolly has been half of a marriage, she knows what a widower like Horace needs, and she has spent the whole film demonstrating it. Horace, cornered by his own loneliness and by Dolly's certainty, comes around. She also gets in her philosophy, scolding him that "Money is like manure, it's not worth anything unless it's spread around," a line the whole plot has been illustrating, since every closed purse in the story, his above all, has been pried open by nightfall. The clerks get their girls, the milliner gets her clerk, the nieces get their escapes, and Dolly gets the richest merchant in Yonkers.

Characters

Dolly Levi (Shirley Booth) is the film's engine and its author: a widow who matches spouses, apprenticeships, suitcases, and social engagements, and who pursues her own happiness with the same shameless ingenuity she lends her clients. She talks directly to the audience throughout, turning her scheming into a warm conspiracy with the viewer.

Horace Vandergelder (Paul Ford) is the pompous, tightfisted merchant the whole ensemble conspires to separate from his fortune. Ford, a specialist in blustering authority, delivers his slow-burning outrage in a voice like a foghorn with a grievance; his verdict on matrimony, "Marriage is a bribe to make a housekeeper think she's a householder," tells you everything about him.

Cornelius Hackl (Anthony Perkins) is Vandergelder's meek chief clerk, thirty-something and adventure-starved, giddily aware that he is spending his one afternoon off. Perkins, two years before Psycho, makes his gawkiness touching.

Barnaby Tucker (Robert Morse) is Cornelius's junior and sidekick, all rubber-faced quick energy, the role that helped carry Morse to Broadway stardom.

Irene Molloy (Shirley MacLaine) is the young widowed milliner meant to be Horace's bride, quick-witted enough to hold a hat shop together during a farce and willing to trade up to a clerk with a future.

Interpretations and controversies

The film is sometimes filed among early LGBTQ-related pictures, and the curiosity is real if accidental: Anthony Perkins and Robert Morse, playing clerks who rehearse what to say to women by practicing on each other, would both later be publicly connected to queer lives (Perkins's homosexuality, Morse's camp Broadway persona), which gives their sweet, awkward double act an afterlife the 1958 audience could not have seen.

Sequels, prequels, and universe

There were none, but the property has a famous afterlife. Wilder's play, itself a reworking of his 1938 comedy The Merchant of Yonkers, opened in Edinburgh in 1954 and on Broadway in 1955, and in 1964 it was turned into the musical Hello, Dolly!, which Barbra Streisand later filmed. The Matchmaker is the non-musical ancestor, and watching it after Hello, Dolly! is like hearing the same jokes in their plainclothes versions.